How to tune vocals so they still sound human
Correct the average pitch of each note, most of the way, and leave everything between the notes alone. Set the key first, use a retune speed of 30 to 80 ms, move note centres 60 to 90% of the way to pitch, keep the singer's vibrato, and skip any note that's already within about 10 cents.
Why tuned vocals sound fake
A sung note is never a flat line. It scoops up from below, settles, wobbles with vibrato and slides into the next note. The settled part is what your ear judges as in or out of tune. The rest is expression.
Automatic tuning sounds artificial when it flattens all of that at once. A fast, full-strength correction pulls the scoop, the vibrato and the slide onto the grid, and the result is the stepped, synthetic sound everyone recognises. The fix is to treat the parts of a note differently.
The settings that matter
| Control | What it does | Natural range |
|---|---|---|
| Key and scale | Which notes are legal targets | Set it correctly, or use chromatic for melodies that leave the scale |
| Strength (amount) | How far each note's centre moves toward the target | 60 to 90% |
| Retune speed | How quickly correction ramps in at the start of a note | 30 to 80 ms |
| Drift | How much slow wander inside a held note is flattened | 30 to 50% |
| Vibrato | Kept, reduced or exaggerated | Leave it as sung |
| Tolerance | Notes closer than this are skipped | 8 to 12 cents |
Order of work
- Set the song's key and scale. A wrong key is the most common cause of notes being pulled to the wrong place.
- Run a gentle global pass: 60 to 80% strength, 45 ms speed, vibrato untouched.
- Listen through once and mark what still bothers you. It's usually 3 to 10 notes in a song.
- Fix those by hand. Move the one flat note at the end of the phrase; pull down the one that overshoots.
- Check any note that was pulled to the wrong neighbour. A blue note between the minor and major third is the usual victim. Set its pitch yourself or exclude it.
- Bypass and compare at the chorus. If the tuned version sounds smaller or stiffer, back the strength off.
What to leave alone
- Scoops and falls. They're phrasing. Tuning them makes the singer sound sequenced.
- Fast runs. Short notes are forgiven by the ear and correction artefacts show most there.
- Notes that are sharp on purpose. Rock and soul singers push the top of a phrase sharp for intensity.
- Breaths and consonants. They have no pitch, and a tuner that tries to find one produces warbles.
How much is enough
Listeners don't need a vocal to be perfect. In our own test mix, a lead vocal averaging 27 cents off pitch came down to 19 cents with correction at 60%. A gentle setting like that leaves most of the performance exactly as sung. How many cents off is noticeable covers where the audible line is.
Quick answers
- What retune speed sounds natural?
- Between 30 and 80 ms for most singing. Under 10 ms the transitions between notes turn into steps, which is the robotic effect.
- Should I tune every note to 100%?
- No. Moving each note 60 to 90% of the way to pitch fixes what listeners notice and leaves the small imperfections that make a voice sound like a person.
- Do I tune before or after compression?
- Before. Pitch detection works best on the clean, unprocessed take.
Audizer does this when you ask.A Mac DAW with an engineer built in. Say what you want and it makes the edit. Free download.
Get Audizer