How many milliseconds off the grid is audible?
Two percussive sounds less than about 10 ms apart are heard as one. Between 10 and 20 ms they still fuse but the pair sounds wider or softer. Past 20 to 30 ms most listeners hear two separate attacks, a flam. Average timing errors under 15 ms sound tight; over 30 ms sounds loose.
What the gap sounds like
| Offset between two hits | What you hear |
|---|---|
| 0 to 5 ms | One hit. Close mics on a kit differ by this much naturally |
| 5 to 10 ms | One hit, slightly thicker |
| 10 to 20 ms | Still one event, with a softened attack. Felt as "ahead" or "behind" |
| 20 to 30 ms | The edge of a flam on sharp sounds like snare and clap |
| 30 to 50 ms | A clear flam on drums. Sustained sounds like pads and vocals still pass |
| Over 50 ms | Two events. Reads as a mistake |
Sharp sounds are judged more harshly than soft ones. A kick and bass 25 ms apart smear the low end. A string pad entering 40 ms late goes unnoticed.
It depends on tempo
The same error is a different fraction of the beat at different tempos.
| Tempo | 16th note lasts | 20 ms is this much of a 16th |
|---|---|---|
| 80 BPM | 187.5 ms | 11% |
| 100 BPM | 150 ms | 13% |
| 120 BPM | 125 ms | 16% |
| 140 BPM | 107 ms | 19% |
| 170 BPM | 88 ms | 23% |
At 170 BPM a 20 ms error is nearly a quarter of the way to the next 16th. Fast music needs tighter playing in absolute terms.
Consistent offset is feel; random offset is slop
A bass player who's 12 ms behind the kick on every note sounds relaxed and deep. A snare that lands 15 ms late on every backbeat makes a groove feel heavy. Listeners hear those as style.
Random scatter is what sounds amateur: one note early, the next late, by amounts that don't repeat. Editing should reduce the scatter and leave the consistent offset. That's the argument for quantizing at 50 to 70% strength. A hit that was 30 ms out lands 9 to 15 ms out, back inside the range where it fuses, and the performance keeps its shape.
Where to spend editing time
- Kick and bass together. This pair defines the low end, and flams between them are the most damaging.
- Anything doubled: stacked guitars, vocal doubles, layered claps. Aim for under 15 ms between the copies.
- The first note of each section. An entry that's late gets noticed.
- Leave fills, pickups and anything rubato alone.
Quick answers
- Can people hear 10 ms of timing error?
- Not as a separate event. Two drum hits 10 ms apart fuse into one. Musicians may feel it as a part sitting slightly ahead or behind.
- How accurate are professional drummers?
- Good session players typically land within 10 to 20 ms of a click on average, and the variation is part of the feel.
Audizer does this when you ask.A Mac DAW with an engineer built in. Say what you want and it makes the edit. Free download.
Get Audizer